Table of Comments
Total Comments in Report: 92
- General Comments (9)
- Introduction (0)
- Part I (0)
- Part II
- A. The External Approach:Building an International Consensus (0)
- 1. The New Diplomatic Offensive (4)
- 2. The Iraq International Support Group (4)
- 3. Dealing with Iran and Syria (7)
- 4. The Wider Regional Context (9)
- B. The Internal Approach: Helping Iraqis Help Themselves (0)
- 1. Performance on Milestones (3)
- 2. National Reconciliation (6)
- 3. Security and Military Forces (4)
- 4. Police and Criminal Justice (2)
- 5. The Oil Sector (1)
- 6. U.S. Economic and Reconstruction Assistance (1)
- 7. Budget Preparation, Presentation, and Review (1)
- 8. U.S. Personnel (2)
- 9. Intelligence (2)
- Appendices (0)
I see the design of this section as significant and generally well conceived. The ISG here prioritizes the tasks required in the broad regional (and international) scene over those required in the internal, inside-Iraq scene. I think that’s quite right for two main reasons:
(1) Let’s face it, there really is not much at all that the US can even hope to achieve inside Iraq these days. Anyway, it should not even really try. Everything iot’s done there over the past three years has made things worse, and nationwide Iraqi polls show that the large majority of Iraqis are now simply eager for the US troops to leave
(2) But what must– and perhaps can– be done is to try to “hold the ring” among all of Iraq’s six neighbors, to try to maximize the chances that (a) they don’t all escalate their interventions inside Iraq and turn the country into even more of an imbroglio than it now is, and (b) that the large inter-group conflicts there don’t spill out and en-”gulf” this whole region in a horrendous shooting war.